Murphy's Law: The Fatal Phony Flaw

Archives

November 16,2008: Jet engine manufacturer Pratt & Whitney has agreed to pay $52 million in fines and costs for supplying the U.S. Air Force with defective replacement turbine blades used in jet engines. One F-16 was lost due to this, although the pilot was able to bail out safely. The blades were slightly off size, and were shipped between 1994 and 2003 (when the F-16 crashed and the defective blades were discovered).

Pratt & Whitney designed the blades, and a subcontractor (which paid $2 million of the fine) manufactured them. The subcontractor cast the blades to the Pratt & Whitney spec. Pratt & Whitney's payments included $5 million for re-inspecting all the blades the air force had in inventory, to see which could still be used. The defect was very minor, which is why so many years went by before it was discovered. Thus some of the blades were fit to be used after the re-inspection.

High tech means high standards and tight tolerances during manufacture. Tiny defects or errors in design can cause equipment to wear out faster or, in this case, fail. This happens in electronics frequently, less so in cases where metal, plastic or composite components are concerned.

 

X

ad

Help Keep StrategyPage Open

First came Facebook, then came Twitter, and finally, AI has arrived. They have all caused a decline in our business, but AI may be the deadliest innovation. We are currently in survival mode. Our writers and staff receive no payment in some months, and even when they do, it is below the minimum wage for their efforts. You can support us with your donations or subscriptions. Please help us keep our doors open.

Make sure you spread the word about us. Two ways to do that are to like us on Facebook and follow us on X.

Subscribe   Donate   Close